Fantasyland, Kurt Andersen (2.0)
My low scoring review for this book comes with a caveat: I
know many people have and will enjoy reading it. The premise was fascinating –
a discussion of how we got to the current state of fake news, science denying,
etc. by reviewing the history of the US as far back as the Salem witch trials.
Unfortunately, my expectation for a non-fiction book filled with statistics is
that the data is backed up with sources. There were many footnotes, but they
were additional rants, not cited references. This was particularly troublesome
when I got to a fact that was doubtful or wrong, all succeeding facts were cast
in that light. Also, while I agreed with much of Mr. Anderson’s assertions, the
childish words he used in his disrespect for virtually everyone who did not
agree with him was distracting and too informal for a serious book. If you are
aghast at much of what is going on in our politics and news with regards to
facts and need a cathartic read to validate those feelings – this book will be
enjoyable. Ironically, just don’t expect actual fact checking for those facts
in the book.
No comments:
Post a Comment